Practical SolutionsEvidence for what works

The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching

evidence-backedimplementable with effort · 6/8design: randomised trial

Giving the poorest households a productive asset, training, a savings account and regular coaching for about two years raised consumption and food security in six countries, with gains lasting after support ended.

Key messages

  • Evidence: evidence-backed. Strongest design cited: randomised trial.
  • Implementation: implementable with effort (6 of 8). Cost to start is high; adoption is scaled.
  • Start with: 300 ultra-poor households: bundle versus cash alone, survey consumption and food security at 12 and 24 months.
  • Main limit: Costly per household compared with cash alone, and results depend on coaching quality and local markets.

Where it works

Six countries on three continents; scaled by BRAC and others.

What it takes

Careful targeting, an asset transfer, 18-24 months of weekly coaching, and a savings account.

Who can act: Social-protection ministries and NGOs such as BRAC.

Cheapest first test

300 ultra-poor households: bundle versus cash alone, survey consumption and food security at 12 and 24 months.

Can it be implemented?

Verdict
implementable with effort · 6/8
Cost to start
high. Asset plus two years of coaching per household.
Real-world adoption
scaled
Delivery channel
BRAC and government social-protection programmes
Holds remit and money
social-protection ministries, BRAC

Score 3 to 8 = cost to start (low 3, medium 2, high 1) + real-world adoption (scaled 3, piloted 2, trial-only 1) + an existing delivery channel (2). 7 or more is ready to implement; 5 or 6 is implementable with effort; below 5 is held back as not yet practical.

Evidence and sources

Randomised trial: Participants or places assigned by chance.

  • Banerjee, Duflo, Goldberg, Karlan, Osei, Parienté, Shapiro, Thuysbaert and Udry, Science, 2015
    Randomised evaluations in Ethiopia, Ghana, Honduras, India, Pakistan and Peru: consumption, assets, food security and income rose in the treated households in five of six countries.
    Find this paper on Europe PMC

Verification: not yet checked against the source No automatic check is defined for this entry yet, so the figures are the source's own, unconfirmed here.

Limits

Costly per household compared with cash alone, and results depend on coaching quality and local markets.

Use and cite this entry

Permanent link: https://ultrastable.org/solutions/graduation

Practical Solutions. "The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/graduation. Accessed 2026-11-17.

This entry as JSON · Compare with others · Report an error or suggest a correction