{"generated":"2026-11-17T14:09:16.625Z","origin":"https://ultrastable.org","labels":{"evidence-backed":"Cites a systematic review or randomised trial, with its own figures.","mixed evidence":"The cited studies disagree or found limited benefit. Shown because a mixed result is part of the evidence.","cited, weaker design":"Cites an observational study or guidance only.","lead":"Found automatically by the loop and checked only mechanically. A place to look, not a conclusion."},"problems":[{"id":"under5","title":"Children dying before age five","domain":"Child health","indicator":"SH.DYN.MORT","value":37.4,"year":2024,"target":25,"target_source":"SDG 3.2: at most 25 per 1,000","shortfall":0.3315508021390374,"rank":5,"solutions":["kmc","ors-zinc","chlorine","itn","immunisation","vita"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/under5"},{"id":"neonatal","title":"Newborn deaths","domain":"Child health","indicator":"SH.DYN.NMRT","value":17.2,"year":2024,"target":12,"target_source":"SDG 3.2: at most 12 per 1,000","shortfall":0.3023255813953488,"rank":7,"solutions":["kmc"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/neonatal"},{"id":"maternal","title":"Mothers dying in childbirth","domain":"Maternal health","indicator":"SH.STA.MMRT","value":197,"year":2023,"target":70,"target_source":"SDG 3.1: below 70 per 100,000","shortfall":0.6446700507614214,"rank":3,"solutions":[],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/maternal"},{"id":"ncd","title":"Early death from heart disease, cancer, diabetes and lung disease","domain":"Chronic disease","indicator":"SH.DYN.NCOM.ZS","value":18.286828600681,"year":2021,"target":12.570996518597733,"target_source":"SDG 3.4: one-third lower than 2015","shortfall":0.3125655195275583,"rank":6,"solutions":["hypertension"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/ncd"},{"id":"suicide","title":"Suicide","domain":"Mental health","indicator":"SH.STA.SUIC.P5","value":9.13023008813063,"year":2021,"target":6.49444356591628,"target_source":"SDG 3.4: one-third lower than 2015","shortfall":0.28868785307403083,"rank":8,"solutions":["friendship-bench"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/suicide"},{"id":"tb","title":"Tuberculosis","domain":"Infectious disease","indicator":"SH.TBS.INCD","value":131,"year":2024,"target":30,"target_source":"WHO End TB: 80% lower than 2015","shortfall":0.7709923664122137,"rank":1,"solutions":[],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/tb"},{"id":"poverty","title":"Extreme poverty","domain":"Poverty","indicator":"SI.POV.DDAY","value":10.1,"year":2024,"target":3,"target_source":"World Bank goal: under 3%","shortfall":0.7029702970297029,"rank":2,"solutions":["cash","mobile-money","graduation"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/poverty"},{"id":"hunger","title":"Chronic hunger","domain":"Food","indicator":"SN.ITK.DEFC.ZS","value":8.1,"year":2024,"target":5,"target_source":"SDG 2.1 proxy: under 5%","shortfall":0.38271604938271603,"rank":4,"solutions":["cash","graduation"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/hunger"},{"id":"water","title":"Unsafe drinking water","domain":"Water","indicator":"SH.H2O.SMDW.ZS","value":73.6686144265244,"year":2024,"target":100,"target_source":"SDG 6.1: universal","shortfall":0.263313855734756,"rank":9,"solutions":["chlorine","women-leaders"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/water"},{"id":"cooking","title":"Smoky cooking fuel","domain":"Energy and air","indicator":"EG.CFT.ACCS.ZS","value":75.424050565184,"year":2024,"target":100,"target_source":"SDG 7.1: universal","shortfall":0.24575949434815997,"rank":10,"solutions":["clean-cooking"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/cooking"},{"id":"education","title":"Children not finishing primary school","domain":"Education","indicator":"SE.PRM.CMPT.ZS","value":88.0215835571289,"year":2024,"target":100,"target_source":"SDG 4.1: universal","shortfall":0.11978416442871094,"rank":11,"solutions":["tarl","deworming"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/education"},{"id":"road","title":"Road traffic deaths","domain":"Safety","indicator":"SH.STA.TRAF.P5","value":null,"year":null,"target":null,"target_source":"SDG 3.6 / UN Decade of Action: halve deaths from 2015","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":["helmets"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/road"},{"id":"electricity","title":"People without electricity","domain":"Energy and air","indicator":"EG.ELC.ACCS.ZS","value":null,"year":null,"target":100,"target_source":"SDG 7.1: universal","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":["rural-electrification"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/electricity"},{"id":"sanitation","title":"Unsafe sanitation","domain":"Water","indicator":"SH.STA.SMSS.ZS","value":null,"year":null,"target":100,"target_source":"SDG 6.2: universal","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":[],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/sanitation"},{"id":"stunting","title":"Stunted growth in children","domain":"Food","indicator":"SH.STA.STNT.ZS","value":null,"year":null,"target":null,"target_source":"WHA 2025 target: 40% fewer than 2012","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":["deworming"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/stunting"},{"id":"air","title":"Polluted air","domain":"Energy and air","indicator":"EN.ATM.PM25.MC.M3","value":null,"year":null,"target":5,"target_source":"WHO 2021 air quality guideline: 5","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":["clean-cooking","emissions-market"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/air"},{"id":"internet","title":"People offline","domain":"Digital access","indicator":"IT.NET.USER.ZS","value":null,"year":null,"target":100,"target_source":"SDG 9.c: universal access","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":[],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/internet"},{"id":"women-power","title":"Women missing from national parliaments","domain":"Governance and gender","indicator":"SG.GEN.PARL.ZS","value":null,"year":null,"target":50,"target_source":"SDG 5.5 / parity: 50%","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":["women-leaders"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/women-power"},{"id":"finance","title":"Adults without a financial account","domain":"Poverty","indicator":"FX.OWN.TOTL.ZS","value":null,"year":null,"target":100,"target_source":"World Bank / G20: universal financial access","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":["mobile-money"],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/finance"},{"id":"birthreg","title":"Children whose birth is never registered","domain":"Governance and gender","indicator":"SP.REG.BRTH.ZS","value":null,"year":null,"target":100,"target_source":"SDG 16.9: universal","shortfall":null,"rank":null,"solutions":[],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/problems/birthreg"}],"solutions":[{"id":"kmc","title":"Start kangaroo mother care at birth for small babies","claim":"Skin-to-skin contact with a parent, begun immediately after birth for babies weighing 1.0 to 1.8 kg, cut deaths in the first 28 days by about a quarter.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"No equipment; training and a ward corner","adoption":"scaled","channel":"newborn wards and national newborn programmes","actors":"ministries of health, district hospitals","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["neonatal","under5"],"domains":["Child health"],"verified":"automatically checked 2026-11-17: the quoted numbers appear in the abstract of \"Immediate \"Kangaroo Mother Care\" and Survival of Infants with Low Birth Weight.\".","works_where":"Tertiary newborn units in Ghana, India, Malawi, Nigeria, Tanzania (2017-2020).","takes":"Train nurses and mothers; a quiet corner with a chair or wrap. No equipment purchase.","who":"District hospital and maternity ward managers; ministries of health.","first_test":"One newborn ward for 3 months: enrol every baby of 1.0-1.8 kg, begin KMC within an hour of stabilisation, compare 28-day survival with the previous 3 months.","limits":"Tested only in tertiary hospital units and only for babies of 1.0-1.8 kg; community-start effect is less certain. Mothers need support to keep it up for many hours a day.","sources":[{"cite":"WHO Immediate KMC Study Group, New England Journal of Medicine, 2021","finding":"Randomised trial in five hospitals in Ghana, India, Malawi, Nigeria and Tanzania: 3,211 babies of 1.0-1.8 kg; about 25% lower neonatal mortality for immediate versus conventional KMC.","links":["https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmoa2026486","https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34038632/","https://europepmc.org/search?query=WHO%20Immediate%20KMC%20Study%20Group%2C%20New%20England%20Journal%20of%20Medicine%2C%202021"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/kmc","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Start kangaroo mother care at birth for small babies\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/kmc. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"ors-zinc","title":"Oral rehydration salts plus zinc as the standard first treatment","claim":"A low-cost treatment pair for children with diarrhoea; zinc shortens episodes and reduces the chance of a repeat episode in following months.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"A few cents a course","adoption":"scaled","channel":"clinics, community health workers, essential-medicines lists","actors":"ministries of health, procurement units","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"review","verdict":"works","problems":["under5"],"domains":["Child health"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Recommended worldwide; coverage of zinc remains low in many countries.","takes":"Stock both at clinics and community health workers; a standard 10-14 day zinc course with clear instructions.","who":"National essential-medicines lists, procurement units, community health programmes.","first_test":"In one district, audit what share of diarrhoea cases get ORS plus zinc, then fix the stock-out and training gap and re-audit after 3 months.","limits":"Treats episodes; does not prevent them. Impact depends on caregivers reaching care early.","sources":[{"cite":"WHO and UNICEF joint statement on diarrhoea management, 2004; Lamberti et al., BMC Public Health, 2011 (zinc meta-analysis)","finding":"Zinc given with ORS reduces duration and severity of acute diarrhoea in children; WHO has recommended the pair since 2004.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=WHO%20and%20UNICEF%20joint%20statement%20on%20diarrhoea%20management%2C%202004%3B%20Lamberti%20et%20al.%2C%20BMC%20Public%20Health%2C%202011%20"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/ors-zinc","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Oral rehydration salts plus zinc as the standard first treatment\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/ors-zinc. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"chlorine","title":"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it","claim":"Free, automatic or supervised chlorine dosing at community water points lowers child mortality.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"Cents per person per year","adoption":"scaled","channel":"village water points and NGO dispenser networks","actors":"water authorities, Evidence Action, village committees","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"review","verdict":"works","problems":["water","under5"],"domains":["Water","Child health"],"verified":"checked 2026-11-16 against the NBER working paper w30835.","works_where":"Trials in Kenya, Uganda, Malawi, among others; scaled by Evidence Action as Dispensers for Safe Water.","takes":"Dispensers or dosing at shared wells and taps, refill logistics, a local promoter, chlorine testing.","who":"Water authorities, NGOs, village committees.","first_test":"20 shared water points: install dispensers, test free chlorine residual at household level monthly, track diarrhoea clinic visits against 20 matched points.","limits":"Effect depends on people using the dispensers; works poorly where households already treat water or sources are piped and treated.","sources":[{"cite":"Kremer, Luby, Maertens, Tan and Wlodarczyk, meta-analysis of water-treatment trials, 2022-2023 (NBER working paper)","finding":"18 randomised trials with mortality data: odds of under-5 death about 24-27% lower (odds ratio 0.76, 95% CI 0.63-0.93); authors estimate USD 28-72 per DALY averted.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Kremer%2C%20Luby%2C%20Maertens%2C%20Tan%20and%20Wlodarczyk%2C%20meta-analysis%20of%20water-treatment%20trials%2C%202022-2023%20"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/chlorine","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Chlorinate water at the point where people collect it\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/chlorine. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"itn","title":"Distribute insecticide-treated bed nets, choosing nets that beat local resistance","claim":"Sleeping under treated nets cuts child deaths in malaria areas; newer dual-insecticide nets work better where mosquitoes resist pyrethroids.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"medium","cost_note":"Nets every 3 years plus resistance monitoring","adoption":"scaled","channel":"national malaria campaigns","actors":"national malaria programmes, Global Fund","score":7,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"review","verdict":"works","problems":["under5"],"domains":["Child health"],"verified":"automatically checked 2026-11-17: the quoted numbers appear in the abstract of \"Insecticide-treated bed nets and curtains for preventing malaria.\".","works_where":"Mass campaigns across sub-Saharan Africa; large trials in Tanzania and Benin.","takes":"Net procurement, a household census, distribution every 3 years, resistance monitoring to pick the net type.","who":"National malaria programmes and funders such as the Global Fund.","first_test":"Before the next campaign, test local mosquito resistance; where resistant, specify dual-insecticide nets for one district and compare malaria cases with neighbours.","limits":"Net use, resistance and seasonality change the benefit; trial-era mortality effects are not guaranteed today.","sources":[{"cite":"Lengeler, Cochrane Review, 2004","finding":"About 17% lower all-cause child mortality in trial settings.","links":["https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.cd000363.pub2","https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15106149/","https://europepmc.org/search?query=Lengeler%2C%20Cochrane%20Review%2C%202004"]},{"cite":"Accrombessi et al., Lancet, 2023 (Benin); Mosha et al., Lancet, 2022 (Tanzania)","finding":"Chlorfenapyr dual-insecticide nets lowered malaria infection versus standard pyrethroid nets in resistance areas.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Accrombessi%20et%20al.%2C%20Lancet%2C%202023%20%3B%20Mosha%20et%20al.%2C%20Lancet%2C%202022%20"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/itn","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Distribute insecticide-treated bed nets, choosing nets that beat local resistance\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/itn. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"tarl","title":"Teaching at the Right Level: group by skill, not grade","claim":"Sorting children by what they can do and teaching basics for about an hour a day raises reading and arithmetic far more than ordinary lessons.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"Regrouping and a trained volunteer or teacher","adoption":"scaled","channel":"primary schools and education departments","actors":"education ministries, Pratham and partners","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["education"],"domains":["Education"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"India (Pratham), then Ghana, Zambia, Nigeria, Kenya and others, delivered by teachers or volunteers.","takes":"A short baseline test, regrouping for a daily block, a trained teacher or volunteer, a simple tracker.","who":"Primary school heads, education departments, NGOs.","first_test":"10 schools: a 10-minute reading test, regroup grades 3-5 for one hour a day for a term, retest and compare with 10 similar schools.","limits":"Needs protected class time. Gains fade if the programme is dropped; rollout quality varies.","sources":[{"cite":"Banerjee, Banerji, Berry, Duflo, Kannan, Mukerji, Shotland and Walton, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2017","finding":"Randomised evaluations of Pratham programmes in India and replications in other countries show large gains in basic literacy and numeracy at low cost.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Banerjee%2C%20Banerji%2C%20Berry%2C%20Duflo%2C%20Kannan%2C%20Mukerji%2C%20Shotland%20and%20Walton%2C%20Journal%20of%20Economic%20Perspectives%2C%202017"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/tarl","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Teaching at the Right Level: group by skill, not grade\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/tarl. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"immunisation","title":"Reliable immunisation camps with a small incentive","claim":"Regular, dependable vaccination sessions plus a small gift raised full immunisation sharply in rural Rajasthan.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"medium","cost_note":"Staffed camps and incentives","adoption":"piloted","channel":"district immunisation services","actors":"district health officers","score":6,"practical":true,"band":"implementable with effort"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["under5"],"domains":["Child health"],"verified":"checked 2026-11-16 against the J-PAL summary.","works_where":"Rural Udaipur, Rajasthan, India; later pilots (for example Haryana) replicate the idea.","takes":"A monthly fixed-day camp with a staffed nurse, a reminder through village volunteers, a bag of lentils or similar.","who":"District health officers, NGOs.","first_test":"10 villages: fixed monthly camp plus incentive, versus the current service; compare full immunisation at 12 months.","limits":"One region; incentive cost and supply reliability are essential, and effects elsewhere need local testing.","sources":[{"cite":"Banerjee, Duflo, Glennerster and Kothari, BMJ, 2010","finding":"Randomised trial: full immunisation among children aged 1-3 was 6.2% in comparison villages, 16.6% with reliable camps, and 38.3% with camps plus incentives.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Banerjee%2C%20Duflo%2C%20Glennerster%20and%20Kothari%2C%20BMJ%2C%202010"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/immunisation","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Reliable immunisation camps with a small incentive\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/immunisation. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"vita","title":"Vitamin A supplementation in deficient populations","claim":"Where children are vitamin A deficient, twice-yearly high-dose capsules reduce child mortality.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"A few cents per capsule","adoption":"scaled","channel":"immunisation contacts and campaigns","actors":"national nutrition programmes","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"review","verdict":"works","problems":["under5"],"domains":["Child health"],"verified":"automatically checked 2026-11-17: the quoted numbers appear in the abstract of \"Vitamin A supplementation for preventing morbidity and mortality in children from six months to five years of age.\".","works_where":"Trials in South Asia and Africa; routine programmes in many countries.","takes":"Capsules (a few cents each) given at 6-month intervals through health contacts or campaigns.","who":"National nutrition and immunisation programmes.","first_test":"Check local deficiency and current coverage; where deficient and coverage is under 80%, add dosing to the next immunisation contact in one district.","limits":"Benefit depends on baseline deficiency; recent surveys show falling deficiency in some countries, so check before scaling.","sources":[{"cite":"Imdad et al., Cochrane Review, 2022","finding":"19 trials, 1.2 million children: risk ratio 0.88 (95% CI 0.83-0.93) for all-cause mortality; high-certainty evidence.","links":["https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.cd008524.pub4","https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35294044/","https://europepmc.org/search?query=Imdad%20et%20al.%2C%20Cochrane%20Review%2C%202022"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/vita","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Vitamin A supplementation in deficient populations\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/vita. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"cash","title":"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households","claim":"Large one-off or regular cash transfers to very poor households raise assets, consumption and food security, and the spending also lifts neighbours' incomes.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"high","cost_note":"The transfer itself is the cost","adoption":"scaled","channel":"mobile money and social-protection payment systems","actors":"social-protection ministries, GiveDirectly","score":6,"practical":true,"band":"implementable with effort"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["poverty","hunger"],"domains":["Poverty","Food"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Rural Kenya; many other countries through GiveDirectly and government programmes.","takes":"Identify households (census or satellite), pay by mobile money, monitor fraud.","who":"Social-protection ministries, NGOs and funders.","first_test":"500 households: transfer a fixed sum, survey consumption and food security at 6 and 12 months against matched villages.","limits":"Effects on long-run income are weaker than on consumption; inflation and targeting errors depend on local markets.","sources":[{"cite":"Egger, Haushofer, Miguel, Niehaus and Walker, Econometrica, 2022 (GiveDirectly in Kenya)","finding":"Randomised study of large transfers in rural Kenya found sizeable local spending effects with limited price inflation.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Egger%2C%20Haushofer%2C%20Miguel%2C%20Niehaus%20and%20Walker%2C%20Econometrica%2C%202022%20"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/cash","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Give unconditional cash directly to poor households\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/cash. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"hypertension","title":"Treat high blood pressure with one standard protocol","claim":"A single simple drug protocol, with follow-up and tracking of who is controlled, raises blood-pressure control far above usual care.","label":"cited, weaker design","implementability":{"cost":"medium","cost_note":"Generic drugs, registry, nurse follow-up","adoption":"scaled","channel":"primary care, WHO HEARTS package","actors":"primary-care networks, ministries of health","score":7,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"observational","verdict":"works","problems":["ncd"],"domains":["Chronic disease"],"verified":"automatically checked 2026-11-17: the quoted numbers appear in the abstract of \"Improved blood pressure control associated with a large-scale hypertension program.\".","works_where":"Kaiser Permanente Northern California; adapted in the WHO HEARTS package.","takes":"Stock a few generic drugs, a protocol, a patient registry, nurse follow-up visits.","who":"Primary-care networks, health ministries.","first_test":"5 clinics: register every adult with high blood pressure, apply one protocol, report the share controlled at 6 months.","limits":"The headline result comes from a US integrated health system; low-income clinics face supply and follow-up barriers.","sources":[{"cite":"Jaffe et al., JAMA, 2013 (Kaiser Permanente Northern California)","finding":"Hypertension control rose from about 44% to about 80% over 2001-2009 after a system-wide protocol and registry.","links":["https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2013.108769","https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23989679/","https://europepmc.org/search?query=Jaffe%20et%20al.%2C%20JAMA%2C%202013%20"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/hypertension","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Treat high blood pressure with one standard protocol\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/hypertension. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"friendship-bench","title":"Lay health workers deliver problem-solving therapy on a bench","claim":"Trained grandmothers delivering brief problem-solving therapy cut symptoms of common mental disorders at low cost.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"Lay worker training and supervision","adoption":"scaled","channel":"primary-care clinics","actors":"municipal health departments","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["suicide"],"domains":["Mental health"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Harare clinics, Zimbabwe; adapted in other countries.","takes":"Lay worker training and supervision, a private place at a clinic, a symptom screening tool.","who":"Primary-care clinics, municipal health departments.","first_test":"4 clinics: train 8 lay workers, screen and treat 200 patients, compare symptoms at 6 months with usual care.","limits":"Measures symptoms, not suicide deaths; severe cases still need specialist care.","sources":[{"cite":"Chibanda et al., JAMA, 2016 (Zimbabwe)","finding":"Randomised trial: lower symptom scores at 6 months than enhanced usual care.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Chibanda%20et%20al.%2C%20JAMA%2C%202016%20"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/friendship-bench","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Lay health workers deliver problem-solving therapy on a bench\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/friendship-bench. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"helmets","title":"Require and enforce motorcycle helmets","claim":"Helmets cut the risk of death and of head injury for motorcycle riders; the benefit is large enough that enforcement is among the cheapest road-safety measures.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"A law, enforcement and a standard","adoption":"scaled","channel":"traffic police and vehicle licensing","actors":"transport ministries, road-safety agencies","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"review","verdict":"works","problems":["road"],"domains":["Safety"],"verified":"automatically checked 2026-11-17: the quoted numbers appear in the abstract of \"Helmets for preventing injury in motorcycle riders.\".","works_where":"Pooled observational studies from Asia, Europe and North America.","takes":"A helmet standard, a law with enforcement, affordable certified helmets, and roadside checks.","who":"Transport ministries, traffic police, road-safety agencies.","first_test":"In one city, measure observed helmet use at 20 junctions, run a 3-month enforcement and certified-helmet drive, re-measure use and compare head-injury admissions.","limits":"The review pools observational studies, not randomised trials; benefit depends on helmet quality and on actual wearing, not just a law.","sources":[{"cite":"Liu, Ivers, Norton, Boufous, Blows and Lo, Cochrane Review, 2008","finding":"Helmets reduced the risk of death by about 42% and of head injury by about 69% in the pooled studies.","links":["https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.cd004333.pub3","https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18254047/","https://europepmc.org/search?query=Liu%2C%20Ivers%2C%20Norton%2C%20Boufous%2C%20Blows%20and%20Lo%2C%20Cochrane%20Review%2C%202008"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/helmets","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Require and enforce motorcycle helmets\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/helmets. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"rural-electrification","title":"Subsidise grid connections for rural households (benefits are smaller than hoped)","claim":"A randomised study found that subsidised connections raised household connections sharply but had little measurable effect on income or schooling in the short run, at high cost per household.","label":"mixed evidence","implementability":{"cost":"high","cost_note":"Grid extension per household","adoption":"scaled","channel":"national utilities","actors":"electricity utilities, development banks","score":6,"practical":true,"band":"implementable with effort"},"design":"trial","verdict":"mixed","problems":["electricity"],"domains":["Energy and air"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Rural western Kenya, 2014-2016.","takes":"Grid extension, a connection subsidy, and follow-up of household outcomes.","who":"Electricity utilities, energy ministries, development banks.","first_test":"Before scaling a grid programme, run a staggered connection subsidy in 20 villages and measure income, enterprise start-up and school hours at 12 months.","limits":"One setting and a short horizon; other technologies (mini-grids, solar) and productive-use support may change the picture. Listed because a mixed result is part of the evidence.","sources":[{"cite":"Lee, Miguel and Wolfram, Journal of Political Economy, 2020 (rural Kenya)","finding":"Randomised connection subsidies increased connections; the authors found limited short-run economic benefits relative to the cost of the grid.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Lee%2C%20Miguel%20and%20Wolfram%2C%20Journal%20of%20Political%20Economy%2C%202020%20"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/rural-electrification","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Subsidise grid connections for rural households (benefits are smaller than hoped)\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/rural-electrification. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"mobile-money","title":"Mobile money agent networks","claim":"Where a mobile money service built a dense agent network, households sent and received money more easily; one study estimates it lifted about 2% of Kenyan households out of poverty.","label":"cited, weaker design","implementability":{"cost":"medium","cost_note":"Regulation plus an agent network","adoption":"scaled","channel":"mobile network operators and agent shops","actors":"central banks, telecom regulators","score":7,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"observational","verdict":"works","problems":["finance","poverty"],"domains":["Poverty"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Kenya, 2008-2014; services of the same kind now run in many countries.","takes":"A regulator that permits non-bank e-money, a mobile network, and a dense agent network of shops.","who":"Central banks, telecom regulators, mobile operators.","first_test":"In one district, map agent density, compare households near and far from agents on remittances and savings after 12 months.","limits":"Observational design with strong controls, not a randomised trial; the effect depends on agent density and on regulation allowing the service.","sources":[{"cite":"Suri and Jack, Science, 2016","finding":"Panel study of Kenyan households 2008-2014: access to M-Pesa agents raised consumption and moved about 194,000 households (2%) above the poverty line; the effect was driven by female-headed households.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Suri%20and%20Jack%2C%20Science%2C%202016"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/mobile-money","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Mobile money agent networks\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/mobile-money. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"women-leaders","title":"Reserve leadership seats for women","claim":"Randomly assigned reservation of village-council head posts for women in India changed what the councils funded, towards the goods women said they wanted, such as drinking water.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"A rule on candidate slots","adoption":"scaled","channel":"party and electoral rules","actors":"legislatures, parties, electoral commissions","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["women-power","water"],"domains":["Governance and gender","Water"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Village councils (panchayats) in India; related studies in other countries.","takes":"A law or party rule reserving seats, a randomised or rotating assignment, and candidate support.","who":"Legislatures, electoral commissions, political parties.","first_test":"Where a party can choose, rotate reserved candidate slots across 20 local districts and track budget lines women ask for.","limits":"Evidence is from local councils in India, not national parliaments; it shows a change in priorities, not that every outcome improves.","sources":[{"cite":"Chattopadhyay and Duflo, Econometrica, 2004","finding":"In West Bengal and Rajasthan, councils with randomly reserved women leaders invested more in drinking water infrastructure and roads; effects followed the priorities of women in those villages.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Chattopadhyay%20and%20Duflo%2C%20Econometrica%2C%202004"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/women-leaders","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Reserve leadership seats for women\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/women-leaders. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"graduation","title":"The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching","claim":"Giving the poorest households a productive asset, training, a savings account and regular coaching for about two years raised consumption and food security in six countries, with gains lasting after support ended.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"high","cost_note":"Asset plus two years of coaching per household","adoption":"scaled","channel":"BRAC and government social-protection programmes","actors":"social-protection ministries, BRAC","score":6,"practical":true,"band":"implementable with effort"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["poverty","hunger"],"domains":["Poverty","Food"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Six countries on three continents; scaled by BRAC and others.","takes":"Careful targeting, an asset transfer, 18-24 months of weekly coaching, and a savings account.","who":"Social-protection ministries and NGOs such as BRAC.","first_test":"300 ultra-poor households: bundle versus cash alone, survey consumption and food security at 12 and 24 months.","limits":"Costly per household compared with cash alone, and results depend on coaching quality and local markets.","sources":[{"cite":"Banerjee, Duflo, Goldberg, Karlan, Osei, Parienté, Shapiro, Thuysbaert and Udry, Science, 2015","finding":"Randomised evaluations in Ethiopia, Ghana, Honduras, India, Pakistan and Peru: consumption, assets, food security and income rose in the treated households in five of six countries.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Banerjee%2C%20Duflo%2C%20Goldberg%2C%20Karlan%2C%20Osei%2C%20Parient%C3%A9%2C%20Shapiro%2C%20Thuysbaert%20and%20Udry%2C%20Science%2C%202015"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/graduation","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"The graduation approach: a bundle of an asset, training, savings and coaching\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/graduation. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"deworming","title":"School-based deworming (evidence is contested)","claim":"An influential trial found that treating schoolchildren for worms raised school attendance, but a later Cochrane review found little effect on growth, school performance or survival for mass treatment.","label":"mixed evidence","implementability":{"cost":"low","cost_note":"Cheap tablets","adoption":"scaled","channel":"school health programmes","actors":"education and health ministries","score":8,"practical":true,"band":"ready to implement"},"design":"review","verdict":"mixed","problems":["education","stunting"],"domains":["Education","Food"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Kenya for the trial; the review pools trials from many countries.","takes":"Cheap tablets, teachers or health workers to give them, and a decision about whether to test first.","who":"Ministries of education and health, school health programmes.","first_test":"Test a sample of 500 children for infection first; target treatment where prevalence is high rather than treating everyone.","limits":"The two sources disagree; treat any claimed large benefit of mass treatment as unconfirmed.","sources":[{"cite":"Miguel and Kremer, Econometrica, 2004 (Kenya)","finding":"Randomised school-level deworming reduced absenteeism and had spillovers to neighbouring schools.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Miguel%20and%20Kremer%2C%20Econometrica%2C%202004%20"]},{"cite":"Taylor-Robinson, Maayan, Soares-Weiser, Donegan and Garner, Cochrane Review, 2019","finding":"Mass deworming of children probably has little or no effect on average weight, school attendance or cognition; treating children known to be infected probably increases weight.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Taylor-Robinson%2C%20Maayan%2C%20Soares-Weiser%2C%20Donegan%20and%20Garner%2C%20Cochrane%20Review%2C%202019"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/deworming","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"School-based deworming (evidence is contested)\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/deworming. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"clean-cooking","title":"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)","claim":"A large multi-country trial that gave households LPG stoves and fuel did not find a significant reduction in severe infant pneumonia, so health benefits are less certain than often assumed.","label":"mixed evidence","implementability":{"cost":"high","cost_note":"Stove plus continuing fuel supply","adoption":"piloted","channel":"clean-cooking programmes","actors":"energy ministries","score":5,"practical":true,"band":"implementable with effort"},"design":"trial","verdict":"mixed","problems":["cooking","air"],"domains":["Energy and air"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Guatemala, India, Peru and Rwanda, 2018-2021.","takes":"Stoves, a reliable fuel supply, and support for exclusive use of the clean stove.","who":"Energy and health ministries, clean-cooking programmes.","first_test":"Measure household exposure (PM2.5) before and after in 100 homes to check the stove is actually used exclusively before claiming health gains.","limits":"Mixed result: mixed fuel use can leave exposure high; exposure and other outcomes (blood pressure, birth weight) have separate reports.","sources":[{"cite":"Clasen and the HAPIN investigators, New England Journal of Medicine, 2022","finding":"Randomised trial of a liquefied petroleum gas stove intervention in Guatemala, India, Peru and Rwanda: no significant reduction in severe pneumonia in infants.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Clasen%20and%20the%20HAPIN%20investigators%2C%20New%20England%20Journal%20of%20Medicine%2C%202022"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/clean-cooking","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"Clean-fuel stoves (the largest trial found no clear pneumonia benefit)\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/clean-cooking. Accessed 2026-11-17."},{"id":"emissions-market","title":"A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring","claim":"A randomised study in Surat, India found that a cap-and-trade market for particulate emissions, with continuous monitors, lowered emissions at the plants in the market relative to plants under standard rules.","label":"evidence-backed","implementability":{"cost":"high","cost_note":"Monitors and a market platform","adoption":"trial-only","channel":null,"actors":"state pollution control boards","score":2,"practical":false,"band":"not yet practical"},"design":"trial","verdict":"works","problems":["air"],"domains":["Energy and air"],"verified":"not yet checked against the source","works_where":"Industrial plants in Surat, Gujarat, India.","takes":"Continuous emission monitors, a permit cap, a trading platform, and an enforcement regime.","who":"State pollution control boards, environment ministries.","first_test":"Install continuous monitors at 50 plants and publish readings; trial a small permit market among them for one year.","limits":"A single city and industry; figures are the authors' own and need re-checking against the paper before use.","sources":[{"cite":"Greenstone, Pande, Ryan and Sudarshan, \"Can Pollution Markets Work in Developing Countries? Experimental Evidence from India\", 2023","finding":"Plants assigned to the market emitted noticeably less particulate matter than control plants; the authors report reductions of about a fifth to a third.","links":["https://europepmc.org/search?query=Greenstone%2C%20Pande%2C%20Ryan%20and%20Sudarshan%2C%20%22Can%20Pollution%20Markets%20Work%20in%20Developing%20Countries%3F%20Experimental%20Evidence%20from%20India%22%2C%202023"]}],"url":"https://ultrastable.org/solutions/emissions-market","cite":"Practical Solutions. \"A regulated pollution market with continuous monitoring\". https://ultrastable.org/solutions/emissions-market. Accessed 2026-11-17."}],"domains":[{"name":"Child health","slug":"child-health","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/child-health"},{"name":"Maternal health","slug":"maternal-health","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/maternal-health"},{"name":"Chronic disease","slug":"chronic-disease","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/chronic-disease"},{"name":"Mental health","slug":"mental-health","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/mental-health"},{"name":"Infectious disease","slug":"infectious-disease","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/infectious-disease"},{"name":"Poverty","slug":"poverty","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/poverty"},{"name":"Food","slug":"food","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/food"},{"name":"Water","slug":"water","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/water"},{"name":"Energy and air","slug":"energy-and-air","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/energy-and-air"},{"name":"Education","slug":"education","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/education"},{"name":"Safety","slug":"safety","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/safety"},{"name":"Digital access","slug":"digital-access","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/digital-access"},{"name":"Governance and gender","slug":"governance-and-gender","url":"https://ultrastable.org/domains/governance-and-gender"}]}